December 8, 2023

Material Design vs. Custom Design: What’s Right for You?

In a world full of digital innovations, user interface design plays a crucial role.

Die Google's Material Design Guidelines have become the trademark of many websites and apps. However, there are many use cases outside Google platforms for which Material Design is also a good choice.

By using this design language, you can often immediately see that the platform or app is connected to Google, which can be an advantage for a company's branding.


What is material design?

Material Design may sound a bit like science fiction, but it's basically a design language developed by Google to create consistent and appealing user interfaces across different platforms. It is based on the idea of physical materials and their movement in space.

The design language was developed by Google in 2014 and is based in part on the card-based layout used in Google Now. The allusion to paper-based design styles was different from the flat design style that was widespread at the time.

Like most design systems, it was designed to create a consistent user experience across devices, platforms, and input methods. Similar to how Apple adopted the principles of flat design as a standard, Google used Material Design to ensure that users have a consistent user experience regardless of how they access its products.

Material Design was developed based on mobile-first thinking, which makes sense when you consider that it was originally designed for the development of Android apps was thought of. It's basically an entire ecosystem and not just a series of style guidelines. Google is constantly maintaining its system. For example, it has extensive documentation on how to use and implement it.

The style guidelines include specifications for everything: typography, grid, space, scale, color, and artwork. Despite all this comprehensive documentation, Material Design remains a fairly flexible design library.

Another major advantage is that user feedback takes the form of haptic feedback and subtle animations. The user experience is also very simplified, which makes interaction more intuitive.


When should you use Material Design?

The answer often lies in the context. Material Design is perfect for applications that require a clear hierarchy, intuitive navigation, and a smooth user experience. Whether you have an app for your business or a webpage Develop for your creative projects — material design could be the key.


Disadvantages of Material Design

Of course, every medal has its downside, and Material Design is no exception. Some developers criticize that the standardized elements could make apps feel too similar. Focusing on animations and shadows could also affect performance. It's important to consider these aspects and consider whether Material Design really fits your project.

Da Movement and animation are promoted in the Material Design guidelines, websites or apps that do not include this can give users the impression that they are missing something. People associate the movement features of Material Design with the visual features, which can result in designs lacking movement.

One solution, of course, is to always incorporate movement into designs that meet Material Design specifications. But extensive animations can be very resource-intensive on mobile devices, resulting in higher data consumption and faster battery draining. It is a tightrope walk that designers must follow when working within the Material Design guidelines.

Beginners will find that the Material Design specification is more complicated and difficult to implement than other styles such as flat design. Because the Material Design system is so extensive, there are many more things to consider and comply with than many new designers would like.

Its completeness can also make some designers feel confined and unable to fully develop their own creativity.

It can also inhibit innovation, as virtually every design challenge has already been planned and solutions offered. While this is helpful in many cases, it can prevent designers from finding new approaches to problems while limiting the number of new ideas that can arise.

One of the biggest problems is the so-called “mystery meat” navigation, which can be found in many mobile design apps. Icons are often used instead of text, and while the icons are sometimes immediately recognizable and quite useful, in other cases they are not.

A circle that shows “Home” is much more difficult to identify than the house icon that used to be used in most Android interfaces. This is a prime example of putting form over function, which is a remnant of the flat design roots of Material Design.

And that doesn't just apply to the bottom navigation bar. Material Design's preference for round, floating action buttons is also a usability issue. These circular buttons only have space for one icon and do not contain any supporting text. And since icons leave so much room for interpretation, users often ask themselves what these buttons actually do.


Why we focus on custom design

Let's take a look at the other side of the coin: Why could a custom design be the better choice for your project?


Uniqueness and brand identity

Imagine you have a great idea for an app or website — something unique that perfectly represents your vision and brand. Here comes that individual design into the game. By designing every element from scratch, you can ensure that your interface is as unique as your idea. A strong individual design strengthens the brand identity and helps to stand out from the crowd.


Optimum adjustment to user needs

Material Design offers a wealth of predefined elements that can make development easier for you. But what if your application has specific requirements that go beyond those standards?

With an individual design, you have full control over every detail. From the color palette to the positioning of the elements, you decide what your interface looks like and how it works. This means that you can make adjustments that fit the exact needs of your users.


Better performance and efficiency

Material Design comes with a lot of predefined animations and shadows that are undoubtedly impressive. But for some projects, these additional visual elements could interfere with load times or consume unnecessary resources.

By using an individual design, every visual element can be optimized. This ensures that your user interface not only looks nice but is also efficient. This is particularly important when performance is critical to the user experience.


Flexibility in innovation design

The digital world is evolving rapidly, and as an innovator, you might always want to be one step ahead. With an individual design, you are not bound by the standards of a design language. You can introduce new concepts and features without sticking to predefined patterns. This allows you to react more flexibly to changes in technology or the needs of your users.


conclusion

When an app is primarily developed for the Android platform, using Material Design is often the easiest choice. Because of the widespread takeover by Google, any app based on Material Design principles will feel like a native app.

Material design provides a solid foundation, but individual design has its unique advantages. Ultimately, the decision depends on what goals you have for your project and what experience you want to offer your users. The trick is finding the right balance — be it by adapting material design or creating your individual designs.

What’s a Rich Text element?

The rich text element allows you to create and format headings, paragraphs, blockquotes, images, and video all in one place instead of having to add and format them individually. Just double-click and easily create content.

Static and dynamic content editing

A rich text element can be used with static or dynamic content. For static content, just drop it into any page and begin editing. For dynamic content, add a rich text field to any collection and then connect a rich text element to that field in the settings panel. Voila!

How to customize formatting for each rich text

Headings, paragraphs, blockquotes, figures, images, and figure captions can all be styled after a class is added to the rich text element using the "When inside of" nested selector system.

Louis Nell
CEO Knguru Studios
Moin ich bin Louis, kreativer Kopf und Gründer von KNGURU Studios. Wenn wir einmal anfangen über Technik, Startups oder Produktdesign zu quatschen kannst du dir sicher sein, das es so schnell kein halten mehr gibt. Deswegen gibt es auch mittlerweile diesen Blog in dem ich meine Reise als Startup- und Agenturgründer dokumentiere.
#design
#app
#mobile
Vera Große
UX Management
Hi, ich bin Vera! Meine Verantwortung liegt im Bereich Projektmanagement und Kundenbetreuung. In diesem Blog teilen wir nicht nur unsere Erfahrungen als Startup- und Agenturgründer, sondern auch unsere Begeisterung für kreative Ideen und visionäre Konzepte.Mit Expertise und Leidenschaft arbeiten wir daran, innovative Projekte zum Leben zu erwecken und gleichzeitig unsere eigene Reise zu dokumentieren.
#design
#app
#mobile

Book yours free Video call

Do you want to talk to our team about your project and just hear what we could do for you? Then simply book a free video call with us now!

1
How can we reach you?
2
Accept our privacy policy
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.